Is It Worth It? Premium Burger Add-Ons Reviewed

We’ve all been there: staring at the menu, tempted by add-ons. Bacon for $1.25? Avocado for $1.50? Truffle aioli for $2? These premium toppings sound delicious—but are they worth the extra cost? This breakdown covers the most popular burger upgrades and how to get the best value, especially when you combine smart ordering with cashback options through Fluz.

The Most Popular Burger Add-Ons (and What You Get)

1. Bacon ($1.00–$1.75)
   Verdict: Usually worth it
   Crispy bacon adds crunch, smoke, and depth. It’s almost always a win.
   Try it at: Five Guys, Wendy’s, BurgerFi
   Save more: Earn cashback at Burger King when you upgrade to a Bacon King or add bacon to your Whopper.
2. Avocado or Guacamole ($1.50–$2.00)
   Verdict: Only if fresh
   Great when creamy and ripe, but easy to overcharge for.
   Try it at: Umami Burger, Smashburger
   Tip: Order gift cards with cashback for places like Shake Shack and use them toward specialty burgers.
3. Fried Egg ($1.00–$1.50)
   Verdict: Yes—for brunch burgers
   A runny yolk takes your burger into brunch territory. Worth it when freshly cooked.
   Try it at: Red Robin, Hopdoddy
4. Truffle Aioli ($1.25–$2.00)
   Verdict: Skip unless it’s quality
   When done well, it adds earthy depth. But artificial truffle oil can overpower your burger.
   Try it at: Shake Shack, The Counter
5. Grilled Onions or Mushrooms ($0.75–$1.50)
   Verdict: Worth it if sautéed fresh
   These umami-rich toppings shine when made to order.
   Try it at: In-N-Out Burger, Habit Burger Grill
6. Jalapeños or Pickled Peppers ($0.50–$1.00)
   Verdict: Great value for spice lovers
   A cheap and tasty way to add zing without changing your burger’s balance.
   Try it at: Whataburger, Carl’s Jr.
7. Premium Cheeses (Swiss, Blue, Pepper Jack) ($0.50–$1.00)
   Verdict: Often worth it
   When you want something stronger than American, these cheeses offer serious flavor upgrades.
   Try it at: Burger Lounge, Culver’s

Are Premium Toppings Ever Free?

Absolutely—especially if you know where to look:

• Five Guys: Includes grilled mushrooms, onions, and sauces in the base price.

• In-N-Out: Order “animal-style” or add grilled onions for free if you’re in the know.

• Shake Shack: Some seasonal burgers include truffle, bacon, or jam without upcharges.

Save on Add-Ons with Cashback

Using Fluz is one of the easiest ways to offset premium burger charges. You can:

• Buy Shake Shack gift cards with cashback

• Get cashback at Burger King and use it on upgrades

• Purchase Panera Bread gift cards online and apply them to upscale sandwiches and add-ons

These small cashback wins add up fast—especially if you’re a frequent burger fan.

Final Thoughts: When to Splurge and When to Skip

Premium toppings can elevate your burger—but only if they bring something special. When you’re ordering from a chain that offers them fresh and flavorful, go for it. And when you’re stacking value with cashback? You’ve got every reason to load up.